• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Pendleton Pike

The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar on Pendleton Pike is a vibrant dining destination located at 10580 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis. This establishment specializes in seafood boils, offering a hands-on experience that showcases the freshest crab, shrimp, and lobster, complemented by flavorful seasonings. Guests can enjoy iconic dishes like the Fire Bomb special and hush puppies, celebrated for their perfect balance of taste and texture. The welcoming staff is dedicated to enhancing your dining experience, providing thoughtful menu suggestions for both first-time visitors and seafood lovers alike. With reasonable prices and a commitment to cleanliness, The Juicy Seafood guarantees a satisfying meal that keeps patrons coming back for more.

The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Pendleton Pike: Reviews & Ratings

Mark Rumney
Mark Rumney

We have been talking about visiting Juicy Seafood as heard great things from those around us. Stopped in recently and had a great meal. Our server was helpful as first time visitors and directed us around the options. We started with hush puppies and they tasted spot on with in my opinion, just right amount of flavor and not just filling. You can definitely create a less hands on meal but we went with the hands on Fire Bomb special. Yes it will be messy lol but so worth it. Added the sausage to one of our orders and recommend you try them . We went hot and the Juicy seasoning. Some places say hot, this actually was . I think next visit may tone it down and try just lower heat level and less seasoning mix. By all means did not take away from it’s wonderful flavor of the crab, shrimp, lobster and sides served. I think I just learned a little about how to approach our next night there. The dish portion is great. Would also recommend leftovers not sit in the original sauce as may become overwhelming to original seafood taste. Just my humble opinion. Look forward to our next stop in.

Debbie Stone
Debbie Stone

First time guest, here. I told that to our server and she was the BEST!! She explained the menu, offered suggestions to ensure my partner and I would have plenty to fill our bellies. We took her advice and we could not have been more satisfied! We will be going back again and again!

mike jones
mike jones

We in recent years used to treat our mother to Juicy’s seafood for her birthday. Sadly she recently passed away at the age 100 yrs.

Denise Worsham
Denise Worsham

It's an amazing place to eat and decent price seafood!!

MomLife Hacks
MomLife Hacks

We had a group of about 15 people for reservations at 8 on 5/21. Our server handled it so graciously (I wish I remembered her name) she was always smiling, polite, and regular checked up on us. As for the food I was impressed I got the Mr. Captain mild Cajun and it was amazing. My daughter got the chicken tender basket it was HUGE. If you order this for your child I would suggest you have them share it! I also got the honey lemon mojitos which is a virgin drink and I loved it! For a seafood boil place the pricing was reasonable. I noticed that it didn’t smell fishy at all which is a good sign of cleanliness.

Leah Kapurch
Leah Kapurch

Cameron was the best! So helpful attentive service. The seasonings on the seafood boil was so delish. Lobster muscles and shrimp. Amazing!. Bloody Mary was made so right, With a crawfish to boot.

The Hellcat
The Hellcat

First time visiting, spent way too much money, no regrets. My friend and I were out and about for some retail therapy today. When lunchtime came along, we were having a hard time deciding what we wanted. This was on our route, and we don't have one at home, so we decided to give it a try. Everything sounded good, so we decided we'd get create your own combos, each order two things, and then share. Well, in an attempt to streamline the process, I ordered everything at once. I realized my error far too late: our waitress had interpreted the order as us each wanting all four things. So... that got expensive. Silver lining, now we have leftovers and we know better for our next visit! Honestly, no regrets; everything was delicious. It's a bit of a drive, but I foresee this becoming a new favorite and a good replacement for Red Lobster, since they've definitely gone downhill over the years.

Qeturah McMiller
Qeturah McMiller

All my husband kept saying was why was this place not packed with people. The fried calamari was so tender and not chewy. I ordered the make your own seafood boil with shrimp and crawfish. Hubby got the fried catfish. Everything was delicious!

Location

Welcome to The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Pendleton Pike, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Indiana. Located at 10580 Pendleton Pike, this vibrant spot has quickly gained a reputation for offering a delightful seafood experience that celebrates freshness and flavor. With a phone number to reach out for reservations or inquiries at +1 317-855-1412, diners are just a call away from embarking on a seafood adventure that won’t disappoint.

The ambiance at The Juicy Seafood is inviting and energetic, making it ideal for both casual diners and larger gatherings. Many guests have praised the attentive staff, who go above and beyond to guide newcomers through the extensive menu filled with tantalizing options. First-time patrons like Mark Rumney and Debbie Stone have shared glowing reviews, emphasizing the staff's ability to make recommendations that ensure an exceptional dining experience. The hush puppies served here receive a nod for their perfect seasoning, setting a flavorful tone for the meal ahead.

But the real star of the show is the main attraction: the seafood boil. Diners are encouraged to roll up their sleeves and dive into the “Fire Bomb special,” a must-try for those who enjoy a hands-on dining experience. With options to customize heat levels and seasoning, each dish is a unique fusion of spice and succulent seafood. Whether it's crab, shrimp, or lobster, the flavors are exquisite and well-balanced. Mike Jones cherished the memories made at Juicy’s for special occasions, emphasizing its significance as a family favorite.

Moreover, the clean and inviting atmosphere confirms the restaurant's commitment to quality. Guests like MomLife Hacks noted the absence of any overpowering fishy odors, which is often a red flag in seafood establishments. Instead, the enticing aroma of well-prepared dishes fills the air, leaving patrons eager to dig in.

For those looking for a well-rounded seafood experience that marries quality with affordability, The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Pendleton Pike delivers on all fronts. Whether you’re planning a casual meal or celebrating a special occasion, indulging in the rich flavors and warm atmosphere of Juicy Seafood promises a rewarding venture that will surely bring you back for more.